Peter Gill, playwright and theatre director
Observer review
Home | Up | News | Productions | Pieces | Résumé | Pictures | Studio | Publications | Links


Bookmark and Share

Say it with Vaseline

A sexual relationship between men that's gentle and true is the triumph of Peter Gill's new play

The York Realist

by Peter Gill

Royal Court, London SW1

Review by Susannah Clapp, The Observer, 13 January 2002

For the past few years the theatre has been behaving like an adopted adolescent with an identity crisis: rootling through recent history in the belief that it will provide a clue about how to proceed. Mid-twentieth-century plays are everywhere. The National has dug up the collected misogynies of John Osborne. Peter Nichols, who has long worn the mantle of neglect, will soon have to assume the unwonted aspect of appreciated dramatist, as his work is regularly staged and admired. And this year it's the turn of Peter Gill to be rediscovered.

Gill is now in his sixties, the author of more than a dozen plays. In the summer, the best theatre outside London — the Sheffield Crucible — is staging a Gill retrospective, producing a new play as well as several he's prepared earlier. But the Royal Court has got in first.

The York Realist is a new play set 40 years ago, the era in which Gill directed — at the age of 25 — D.H. Lawrence's A Collier's Friday Night at the Court. The love affair between a free-and-easy farm labourer and an uptight lad from London, who meet during a staging of the York Mystery Plays, is examined with pre-twenty-first-century decorum but with modern insouciance. There's no onstage gritted-teeth buggery, just a confidently flourished jar of Vaseline. There's no moral breast-beating, but a high emotional charge. It's a play which contains some of the most truthful and distinguished theatrical moments of the past few months. And some of the most absurd and artificial.

The opening scene, of snail-like slowness, is disastrously derivative. In front of an old-fashioned range, with a kitchen sink just in sight, the two young men trade terse monosyllables and pregnant pauses. It's as if someone had been challenged to write Sons and Lovers in the style of early Pinter. The audience seems to be destined for an evening clad in corduroyed earnestness.

But the play's triumph is to move on from this; to show, in particular, a sexual relationship between two men which is heartfelt, gentle and not self-evidently doomed. This is helped by the thrilling voice of Lloyd Owen, whose bass reverberations are likely to be rivalled only by Paul Scofield. Anne Reid, both kind and withholding, is perfectly judged as the mother, who offers the best criticism of the incomer's painstakingly authentic, colonising production of the Mysteries: 'It was very Yorkshire, wasn't it? Not that I mind.' Even William Dudley's design — which at first sight seems dully literal-minded — turns out to be expressive: its clutter and corners prove always slightly too small for people on the brink of a more expansive time.

The slow-burning sympathy of Gill's play is a credit to the Court, but unlikely to burnish its much vaunted 'cutting-edge' reputation.

Home | Up | Spectator review | Stage interview | IHT review | Stage review | FT interview | Guardian review | NY Times review | TLS review | Herald review | Time Out review | London Theatre Guide review | Online review | Mail on Sunday review | Sunday Times review | Observer review | Sunday Telegraph review | BBC Arts review | FT review | Rainbownetwork review | Times review | Telegraph review | Guardian review | Standard review | Daily Mail review | Morning Star review | whatsonstage review | BBC Bristol review | Nowt2Do review | BBC Manchester review | Manchester Evening News | Anne Reid | Ian Mercer

Send mail to with questions or comments about this web site.  Copyright © 1999-2012

Last modified: 2012-03-15